|Played by||Margarita Lozano|
|Appears in||A Fistful of Dollars|
Consuela Baxter is the wife of Sheriff John Baxter and mother of Antonio Baxter. Joe sneaks up on her while she is undressing and convinces her that their are two "survivors" of the Mexican army massacre done by the Rojos. She tells her husband which lures them into a shootout at the cemetery. This results in the capture of Antonio. Thankfully, the Baxters have Marisol and trade her for Antonio. However, after Joe frees Marisol and escapes from the Rojos, the Rojos suspect the Baxters of hiding them and set fire to their house and shooting the surivors, including John, Antonio, and Consuela.